> ## Documentation Index
> Fetch the complete documentation index at: https://docs.mixpanel.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover all available pages before exploring further.

# Retain Your Users

export const ZipRecruiterLogo = () => {
  return <svg width="140" height="82" viewBox="0 0 140 82" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
      <path d="M108.395 8.07295C108.395 7.19407 109.114 6.5105 110.063 6.5105C111.077 6.5105 111.765 7.22662 111.765 8.07295C111.765 8.91929 111.045 9.63541 110.063 9.63541C109.114 9.66796 108.395 8.91929 108.395 8.07295ZM111.274 11.4908C111.339 11.4908 111.405 11.5559 111.405 11.621V21.8747C111.405 21.9398 111.339 22.0049 111.274 22.0049H108.885C108.82 22.0049 108.754 21.9398 108.754 21.8747V11.621C108.754 11.5559 108.82 11.4908 108.885 11.4908H111.274V11.4908ZM24.1133 19.4659L32.2928 9.11459C32.3255 9.08204 32.2928 9.01694 32.2273 9.01694H24.3423C24.2769 9.01694 24.2114 8.95184 24.2114 8.88673V6.6407C24.2114 6.5756 24.2769 6.5105 24.3423 6.5105H36.0553C36.1208 6.5105 36.1862 6.5756 36.1862 6.6407V8.95184C36.1862 8.98439 36.1862 9.01694 36.1535 9.04949L27.8758 19.4008C27.8431 19.4333 27.8758 19.4984 27.9413 19.4984H36.0553C36.1208 19.4984 36.1862 19.5635 36.1862 19.6286V21.8747C36.1862 21.9398 36.1208 22.0049 36.0553 22.0049H24.2114C24.146 22.0049 24.0806 21.9398 24.0806 21.8747V19.5635C24.0806 19.531 24.1133 19.4984 24.1133 19.4659V19.4659ZM55.4243 6.6407C55.4243 6.5756 55.4898 6.5105 55.5552 6.5105H60.4302C64.9125 6.5105 66.6466 8.13806 66.6466 10.9375C66.6466 13.8345 64.5526 15.0389 63.1457 15.2017C63.113 15.2017 63.0803 15.2342 63.113 15.2668L67.0719 21.8421C67.1046 21.9072 67.0719 22.0049 66.9737 22.0049H63.8983C63.8328 22.0049 63.7674 21.9723 63.7674 21.9072L60.2339 15.4946C60.2011 15.4621 60.1684 15.4295 60.1357 15.4295H58.2381C58.2053 15.4295 58.1726 15.4621 58.1726 15.4946V21.8747C58.1726 21.9398 58.1072 22.0049 58.0417 22.0049H55.5225C55.457 22.0049 55.3916 21.9398 55.3916 21.8747V6.6407H55.4243ZM60.5283 13.0533C62.5568 13.0533 63.8983 12.5976 63.8983 10.9049C63.8983 9.47266 62.9494 8.85418 60.5937 8.85418H58.2708C58.2381 8.85418 58.2053 8.88673 58.2053 8.91929V12.9882C58.2053 13.0207 58.2381 13.0533 58.2708 13.0533H60.5283V13.0533ZM86.6699 14.5506C86.6045 14.6157 86.539 14.6157 86.4736 14.5506C86.1791 14.2902 85.4266 13.6067 84.4124 13.6067C83.2345 13.6067 81.4678 14.3879 81.4678 16.7641C81.4678 19.2055 83.3981 19.9216 84.4778 19.9216C85.4594 19.9216 86.2773 19.3031 86.5063 19.0427C86.5718 18.9776 86.6372 18.9776 86.7026 19.0427L88.2731 20.7354C88.3385 20.8005 88.3058 20.8656 88.2731 20.9307C87.4879 21.6468 86.2446 22.2978 84.576 22.2978C81.8931 22.2978 78.8503 20.5726 78.8503 16.7967C78.8503 13.1184 81.7295 11.2955 84.576 11.2955C86.1464 11.2955 87.357 11.914 88.3058 12.7929C88.3712 12.858 88.3712 12.9231 88.3058 12.9882L86.6699 14.5506V14.5506ZM69.8202 17.6756C69.7875 17.6756 69.7548 17.7081 69.7548 17.7407C69.8856 18.945 71.1943 20.1494 72.5685 20.1494C74.0081 20.1494 74.6952 19.5635 75.3168 18.8148C75.3495 18.7497 75.4477 18.7497 75.4804 18.7823L77.149 20.0518C77.2144 20.0843 77.2144 20.182 77.1817 20.2471C76.102 21.484 74.7279 22.2327 72.7975 22.2327C69.7548 22.2327 67.0719 20.182 67.0719 16.7316C67.0719 13.4113 69.5912 11.2304 72.6339 11.2304C75.5131 11.2304 77.7379 13.6392 77.7379 16.9269V17.5128C77.7379 17.5779 77.6725 17.643 77.6071 17.643L69.8202 17.6756V17.6756ZM75.0878 15.6899C75.1205 15.6899 75.1532 15.6574 75.1532 15.6248C75.1532 14.3553 74.0081 13.1835 72.5685 13.1835C71.1289 13.1835 69.9511 14.0624 69.7875 15.5923C69.7875 15.6248 69.8202 15.6574 69.8529 15.6574L75.0878 15.6899V15.6899ZM123.968 17.6756C123.936 17.6756 123.903 17.7081 123.903 17.7407C124.034 18.945 125.342 20.1494 126.717 20.1494C128.156 20.1494 128.843 19.5635 129.465 18.8148C129.498 18.7497 129.596 18.7497 129.629 18.7823L131.297 20.0518C131.363 20.0843 131.363 20.182 131.33 20.2471C130.25 21.484 128.876 22.2327 126.946 22.2327C123.903 22.2327 121.22 20.182 121.22 16.7316C121.22 13.4113 123.739 11.2304 126.782 11.2304C129.661 11.2304 131.886 13.6392 131.886 16.9269V17.5128C131.886 17.5779 131.821 17.643 131.755 17.643L123.968 17.6756V17.6756ZM129.236 15.6899C129.269 15.6899 129.301 15.6574 129.301 15.6248C129.301 14.3553 128.156 13.1835 126.717 13.1835C125.277 13.1835 124.099 14.0624 123.936 15.5923C123.936 15.6248 123.968 15.6574 124.001 15.6574L129.236 15.6899ZM89.7781 11.4908H91.8393C91.9048 11.4908 91.9702 11.5234 91.9702 11.5885L92.2647 13.1509H92.2974C93.4098 11.0026 96.0272 11.3281 96.2563 11.3606C96.3217 11.3606 96.3544 11.4257 96.3544 11.5559V13.5741C96.3544 13.6392 96.289 13.7043 96.2235 13.7043C96.2235 13.7043 95.7328 13.6067 95.3074 13.6067C93.6061 13.6067 92.3955 15.1366 92.2647 17.1873V21.8421C92.2647 21.9072 92.1992 21.9723 92.1338 21.9723H89.7454C89.68 21.9723 89.6145 21.9072 89.6145 21.8421V11.621C89.6472 11.5559 89.7127 11.4908 89.7781 11.4908V11.4908ZM133.424 11.4908H135.485C135.55 11.4908 135.616 11.5234 135.616 11.5885L135.91 13.1509H135.943C137.055 11.0026 139.673 11.3281 139.902 11.3606C139.967 11.3606 140 11.4257 140 11.5559V13.5741C140 13.6392 139.935 13.7043 139.869 13.7043C139.869 13.7043 139.378 13.6067 138.953 13.6067C137.252 13.6067 136.041 15.1366 135.91 17.1873V21.8421C135.91 21.9072 135.845 21.9723 135.779 21.9723H133.391C133.326 21.9723 133.26 21.9072 133.26 21.8421V11.621C133.293 11.5559 133.358 11.4908 133.424 11.4908V11.4908ZM112.779 13.6067V11.621C112.779 11.5559 112.844 11.4908 112.91 11.4908H114.905C114.938 11.4908 114.971 11.4583 114.971 11.4257V9.50521C114.971 9.4401 115.004 9.40755 115.069 9.375L117.457 8.49612C117.556 8.46357 117.621 8.52867 117.621 8.62632V11.4257C117.621 11.4583 117.654 11.4908 117.686 11.4908H120.402C120.468 11.4908 120.533 11.5559 120.533 11.621V13.6067C120.533 13.6718 120.468 13.7369 120.402 13.7369H117.686C117.654 13.7369 117.621 13.7694 117.621 13.802V18.3266C117.621 19.238 117.785 20.0192 119.093 20.0192C119.584 20.0192 120.075 19.9216 120.402 19.7914C120.468 19.7588 120.533 19.8239 120.533 19.889V21.8096C120.533 21.8747 120.5 21.9398 120.435 21.9723C120.009 22.1676 119.192 22.2653 118.439 22.2653C117.163 22.2653 116.312 22.0049 115.822 21.5166C115.364 21.0609 115.004 20.3448 115.004 18.5544V13.802C115.004 13.7694 114.971 13.7369 114.938 13.7369H112.942C112.844 13.7369 112.779 13.6718 112.779 13.6067V13.6067ZM102.145 19.9867C101.099 19.9867 100.215 19.3357 100.182 18.1638V11.621C100.182 11.5559 100.117 11.4908 100.052 11.4908H97.6631C97.5977 11.4908 97.5323 11.5559 97.5323 11.621V17.8709C97.5323 20.4424 99.4626 22.2653 102.113 22.2653H102.178C104.828 22.2653 106.759 20.4424 106.759 17.8709V11.621C106.759 11.5559 106.693 11.4908 106.628 11.4908H104.239C104.174 11.4908 104.109 11.5559 104.109 11.621V18.1638C104.076 19.3357 103.192 19.9867 102.145 19.9867V19.9867ZM45.3145 20.7354C45.3145 20.7028 45.3799 20.6703 45.4126 20.7028C46.0997 21.5817 47.4739 22.2653 48.9789 22.2653C51.5309 22.2653 54.0829 20.2796 54.0829 16.7641C54.0829 13.0207 51.5309 11.263 48.8807 11.263C47.2121 11.263 45.9361 12.0767 45.2818 13.0533C45.249 13.0858 45.2163 13.0858 45.1836 13.0207L44.8892 11.621C44.8892 11.5559 44.8237 11.5234 44.7583 11.5234H42.8279C42.7625 11.5234 42.6971 11.5885 42.6971 11.6536V26.8875C42.6971 26.9526 42.7625 27.0177 42.8279 27.0177H45.2163C45.2818 27.0177 45.3472 26.9526 45.3472 26.8875V20.7354H45.3145ZM48.6517 19.889C46.9177 19.889 45.5435 18.7172 45.5435 16.7316C45.5435 14.7459 46.9177 13.5741 48.6517 13.5741C49.666 13.5741 51.4982 14.2577 51.4982 16.7316C51.4982 19.2055 49.6005 19.889 48.6517 19.889ZM37.5603 8.07295C37.5603 7.19407 38.2801 6.5105 39.229 6.5105C40.2432 6.5105 40.9303 7.22662 40.9303 8.07295C40.9303 8.91929 40.2105 9.63541 39.229 9.63541C38.2801 9.66796 37.5603 8.91929 37.5603 8.07295ZM40.4395 11.4908C40.505 11.4908 40.5704 11.5559 40.5704 11.621V21.8747C40.5704 21.9398 40.505 22.0049 40.4395 22.0049H38.0511C37.9857 22.0049 37.9202 21.9398 37.9202 21.8747V11.621C37.9202 11.5559 37.9857 11.4908 38.0511 11.4908H40.4395V11.4908Z" fill="currentColor" />
      <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M17.3078 8.62606C17.1115 8.56096 16.8824 8.59351 16.6534 8.65861L15.77 8.95157V0.781228C15.77 0.358063 15.4101 0 14.9848 0H3.36994C2.94461 0 2.58471 0.358063 2.58471 0.781228V8.98413L1.70133 8.69116C1.47231 8.62606 1.24328 8.59351 1.04697 8.65861C0.719794 8.72372 0 9.04923 0 10.3187V17.1545C0.0981537 17.7404 0.490768 18.424 1.37415 18.424H4.31876C4.61322 18.782 5.33302 19.368 6.70717 19.4656C6.73989 20.4747 7.32881 21.321 8.21219 21.6791V23.5996C8.21219 23.6322 8.17948 23.6647 8.14676 23.6647C4.0243 23.7949 1.40687 25.097 0.654358 25.5201C0.196307 25.7805 0.0981537 26.3339 0.0981537 26.692V28.1893C0.130872 28.7101 0.556204 29.1333 1.11241 29.1333C1.60318 29.1333 2.02851 28.7101 2.06123 28.2219C2.09395 27.7336 1.76677 27.343 1.30872 27.2128C1.276 27.2128 1.24328 27.1802 1.24328 27.1477V26.5943C1.24328 26.4641 1.30872 26.3339 1.43959 26.2688C2.552 25.6503 5.39845 25.3574 7.55784 25.2272H8.17948C8.21219 25.2272 8.24491 25.2597 8.24491 25.2923C8.34307 27.0175 8.53937 28.4823 8.60481 29.3937H8.53937C8.17948 29.3937 7.8523 29.8169 7.8523 30.3703C7.8523 30.9236 8.17948 31.3468 8.53937 31.3468H9.84809C10.208 31.3468 10.5352 30.9236 10.5352 30.3703C10.5352 29.8169 10.208 29.3937 9.84809 29.3937H9.78265C9.78265 29.3937 10.0117 27.0175 10.1426 25.2923C10.1426 25.2597 10.1753 25.2272 10.208 25.2272H10.8296C12.989 25.3248 15.8355 25.6503 16.9479 26.2688C17.0787 26.3339 17.1442 26.4641 17.1442 26.5943V27.1477C17.1442 27.1802 17.1115 27.2128 17.0787 27.2128C16.6207 27.3104 16.2935 27.7336 16.3262 28.2219C16.359 28.7101 16.7843 29.1333 17.2751 29.1333C17.7985 29.1333 18.2566 28.7427 18.2893 28.1893V26.692C18.2893 26.3339 18.1912 25.8131 17.7331 25.5201C16.9806 25.097 14.3304 23.7949 10.2407 23.6322C10.208 23.6322 10.1753 23.5996 10.1753 23.5671V21.6465C11.0587 21.2885 11.6476 20.4421 11.6803 19.4331C13.0217 19.3354 13.7415 18.7169 14.0687 18.3914H17.0133C17.8967 18.3914 18.2893 17.7078 18.3875 17.1219V10.2862C18.3547 9.01668 17.635 8.72372 17.3078 8.62606ZM2.58471 15.7222L1.24328 16.7313C1.21056 16.7639 1.17784 16.7313 1.17784 16.6988V10.2862C1.17784 10.0258 1.21056 9.70025 1.34143 9.7328L2.51928 10.1234C2.552 10.1234 2.58471 10.1885 2.58471 10.2211V15.7222V15.7222ZM17.1442 16.7313L15.8027 15.7222V10.2536C15.8027 10.2211 15.8355 10.1885 15.8682 10.156L17.046 9.76535C17.2096 9.7328 17.2096 10.0583 17.2096 10.3187V16.7313C17.2096 16.7313 17.1769 16.7639 17.1442 16.7313Z" fill="currentColor" />
    </svg>;
};

export const VrboLogo = () => {
  return <svg width="140" height="82" viewBox="0 0 140 82" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
      <g clip-path="url(#clip0_4_259)">
        <path d="M116.16 13.6541V13.7174C124.323 14.4038 126.72 20.2013 126.604 23.5699C126.414 33.3273 118.853 41.184 106.656 42.1449V42.1977C120.057 41.3952 127.903 34.4678 128.072 24.5414C128.051 20.8877 125.389 14.1926 116.16 13.6541Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M106.656 42.0289C111.633 41.6955 116.305 39.5125 119.754 35.9092C123.203 32.3059 125.179 27.5429 125.294 22.5563C125.294 19.4728 123.182 14.404 116.086 13.8337V13.8865C121.957 14.5096 124.027 18.7864 123.985 21.5848C123.816 30.9937 116.519 40.9624 106.719 41.9656L106.656 42.0289Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M106.741 41.8492C115.41 40.9516 122.391 29.8002 122.581 20.5602C122.581 18.0575 120.986 14.5621 116.034 14.0024V14.0658C119.93 14.6572 121.314 17.3711 121.314 19.5992C121.155 28.6492 114.354 40.7932 106.889 41.7752L106.741 41.8492Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M106.857 41.6065V41.6804C113.193 40.7617 119.729 27.4455 119.888 18.5751C119.931 17.4755 119.544 16.4022 118.809 15.5837C118.073 14.7652 117.047 14.2661 115.949 14.1927V14.2561C116.723 14.3861 117.418 14.8053 117.895 15.4287C118.371 16.0522 118.593 16.8334 118.515 17.6141C118.272 26.2839 111.936 40.6666 106.857 41.6065ZM102.876 38.1639C103.023 29.8215 109.602 15.1642 114.492 14.1716V14.0977C108.367 15.0058 101.598 28.5543 101.439 37.1501C101.398 37.7038 101.468 38.2602 101.645 38.7864C101.823 39.3125 102.104 39.7977 102.472 40.2133C102.84 40.6288 103.288 40.9662 103.789 41.2055C104.29 41.4448 104.834 41.5812 105.389 41.6065V41.5431C105.001 41.4889 104.627 41.3581 104.29 41.1583C103.953 40.9585 103.659 40.6937 103.425 40.3793C103.191 40.0649 103.022 39.7071 102.928 39.3268C102.834 38.9465 102.816 38.5512 102.876 38.1639Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M100.183 36.1786C100.341 27.361 107.427 14.9846 114.629 14.0026V13.9392C106.181 14.8368 98.9683 26.1571 98.7888 35.1648C98.7888 37.6781 100.436 41.3952 105.336 41.7965V41.7331C101.513 41.2368 100.14 38.4067 100.183 36.1786Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M97.4899 34.1932C97.6483 24.9532 105.178 14.8156 114.713 13.8124V13.749C109.778 14.1639 105.163 16.3657 101.735 19.9411C98.3074 23.5166 96.3023 28.2201 96.0959 33.1689C96.0959 36.2524 98.208 41.4901 105.315 41.9548V41.8914C99.19 41.3423 97.4476 36.9599 97.4899 34.1932Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M94.7974 32.2082C94.9664 22.5035 103.33 14.5624 114.798 13.6437V13.5803C101.957 14.3723 93.5513 21.2997 93.3824 31.1838C93.3085 34.8376 95.9801 41.596 105.199 42.124C97.1523 41.4904 94.7446 35.5768 94.7974 32.2082ZM88.2713 13.7915C83.8467 13.1896 78.5033 15.7874 75.4937 20.3493L75.5465 20.4232C78.3977 16.3259 83.2131 13.8866 87.1625 14.4357C89.8237 14.7947 91.6505 16.8117 91.2809 20.7717C90.3411 30.8565 81.8403 42.1874 68.239 42.1557V42.2296C74.3062 42.4629 80.2347 40.378 84.8204 36.3984C89.406 32.4188 92.3049 26.843 92.9283 20.8034C93.2979 16.4315 91.2704 14.2034 88.2713 13.7915Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M89.6861 20.7294C90.0135 17.2552 88.4612 15.4494 86.0218 15.1221C82.5053 14.6469 78.2285 16.7906 75.6413 20.5605L75.6941 20.6238C78.0701 17.3714 81.8717 15.3438 84.9236 15.7662C87.0356 16.0514 88.4295 17.6354 88.0916 20.6978C87.2784 29.3781 78.9994 41.3109 68.281 41.9762C80.256 41.9656 88.7991 30.1912 89.6861 20.7294Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M68.4287 41.7648V41.8281C78.4079 40.6348 85.7999 28.512 86.5919 20.6553C86.8242 18.0787 85.6415 16.7059 83.878 16.4313C81.2169 16.0617 77.901 17.8569 75.8524 20.7292V20.7926C77.806 18.2688 80.5305 16.7692 82.6847 17.0649C84.2054 17.2761 85.1346 18.4272 84.934 20.5286C84.2687 27.6883 77.4786 39.8745 68.4287 41.7648Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M68.5449 41.5219V41.617C75.9369 39.6317 82.7904 26.833 83.3289 20.497C83.4768 18.8813 82.7587 17.9309 81.576 17.7725C79.8124 17.5296 77.5737 18.8285 75.9369 20.9405V21.0038C77.2992 19.3776 79.1049 18.2266 80.4249 18.4061C81.2803 18.5222 81.84 19.272 81.7238 20.4653C81.312 25.9987 74.976 38.7763 68.5449 41.5219ZM67.3833 34.3306C66.5976 36.0538 66.0368 37.8709 65.7148 39.7373C65.7259 40.0899 65.8292 40.4334 66.0145 40.7336C66.1998 41.0338 66.4606 41.2801 66.7708 41.448C66.8726 41.4993 66.9786 41.5416 67.0876 41.5747V41.4797C66.9378 41.3344 66.8265 41.154 66.7638 40.9549C66.7011 40.7558 66.689 40.5442 66.7286 40.3392C67.1651 38.445 67.806 36.6038 68.64 34.848L82.368 0L80.4355 0.38016C80.5411 0.82368 76.8345 9.93696 76.6867 10.391L67.3833 34.3306Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M64.8594 33.2428C64.1616 34.9149 63.6585 36.6618 63.3599 38.4489C63.191 40.3603 64.8594 41.3951 67.0982 41.7331V41.6697C65.567 41.3951 64.3842 40.6137 64.5215 39.1353C64.8732 37.3247 65.4111 35.5553 66.1266 33.8553L75.2716 10.3276C75.4934 9.70457 78.9676 1.29881 78.4396 0.760254L76.5599 1.14041V1.24601C76.6338 3.29465 74.2578 8.90201 73.7721 10.222L64.8594 33.2428Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M70.921 10.1058L62.304 32.1656C61.6153 33.7205 61.1256 35.3562 60.8467 37.0338C60.6144 39.7266 62.8215 41.5852 66.9504 41.8703C66.0996 41.7764 65.2629 41.5814 64.4583 41.2895C63.7036 41.1063 63.0426 40.6523 62.6006 40.0137C62.1587 39.3752 61.9667 38.5966 62.0611 37.8258C62.3593 36.0711 62.8773 34.361 63.6029 32.7359L72.3888 10.1586C72.8323 8.96531 75.3456 3.26291 74.7437 1.52051L72.9274 1.87955V1.98515C73.92 3.34739 71.5018 8.62739 70.921 10.1058Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M67.7952 10.5599L59.833 31.0886C59.1758 32.5459 58.7278 34.0889 58.5024 35.6716C58.2173 39.0402 61.1424 41.7964 66.9504 42.0076C62.0823 41.733 59.4317 39.431 59.6957 36.3897C59.94 34.7628 60.4091 33.1777 61.0896 31.6799L69.3159 10.5599C70.0551 8.62744 72.241 3.886 71.0583 2.302L69.1891 2.68216V2.78776C70.4563 4.53016 68.64 8.44792 67.7952 10.5599Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M66.8661 42.1344C60.3084 41.8493 57.0031 38.6496 57.3621 34.9325C57.5576 33.4466 57.9629 31.996 58.566 30.624L66.1586 11.0036C67.109 8.55364 68.8831 4.85764 67.4892 3.03076L65.7679 3.3898V3.4954C67.2357 5.14276 65.8735 7.84612 64.8703 10.5812L57.3093 30.0116C56.6994 31.3494 56.3039 32.7748 56.1372 34.2356C55.7781 38.28 59.3791 41.9444 66.845 42.1661L66.8661 42.1344ZM58.228 17.4029C58.0908 14.7946 56.549 13.6013 54.6799 13.6013C51.2796 13.6013 48.3439 16.2836 46.4959 19.9373V18.649C46.348 15.8084 44.3839 13.6013 40.8885 13.6013C33.4965 13.6013 29.8533 18.4695 28.6389 23.9818H28.7023C29.9906 18.818 33.4332 14.161 40.0754 14.161C40.7114 14.1043 41.3522 14.1793 41.9579 14.3813C42.5636 14.5833 43.1211 14.908 43.5958 15.3351C44.0704 15.7621 44.4519 16.2824 44.7165 16.8635C44.9811 17.4446 45.1231 18.074 45.1336 18.7124C45.3132 22.0599 44.2044 24.6682 43.0216 27.6778L37.636 41.7543H39.0722L44.4578 27.794C44.8168 26.833 45.1548 25.9354 45.461 25.0695C46.517 22.8519 47.837 20.5815 48.5234 20.5815C49.0303 20.5815 49.1887 21.0144 49.2204 21.4052C49.2263 23.5067 48.6762 25.5724 47.6258 27.3927L47.6892 27.456C49.3274 25.608 50.3044 23.2675 50.4664 20.8032C50.4664 20.0746 50.1074 19.5572 49.4104 19.5572C48.2594 19.5572 46.7916 21.9226 45.7144 24.4253C45.8412 24.024 45.9468 23.6228 46.0524 23.232C47.2034 20.7293 48.798 18.5962 50.2764 18.5962C51.1845 18.5962 51.7336 19.2192 51.7864 20.2436C51.9132 22.7357 49.6744 26.3684 47.7948 27.5616L47.8581 27.625C50.4136 26.4845 53.2226 22.7357 53.0642 19.6733C52.9903 18.3111 52.2722 17.5613 51.1317 17.5613C49.252 17.5613 47.4357 19.7472 46.1791 22.4506C46.1791 22.2394 46.2636 22.0282 46.2952 21.8064C47.6997 18.9024 49.7589 16.6004 52.0504 16.6004C53.2965 16.6004 54.2469 17.4452 54.3314 19.0925C54.532 22.7252 51.1 26.5901 47.9954 27.72L48.0588 27.7834C51.8709 26.8119 55.852 22.7252 55.6303 18.5223C55.5247 16.537 54.3948 15.576 52.9269 15.576C50.2869 15.5866 47.932 17.952 46.4642 21.12V20.6026C48.1432 17.2023 50.7938 14.6256 53.8562 14.6256C55.5036 14.6256 56.8658 15.6816 57.0242 17.9837C57.2776 22.8096 52.8002 26.8964 48.2383 27.9207L48.3016 27.9735C53.5816 27.1709 58.5132 22.7991 58.228 17.4029Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M43.8134 18.8179C43.8034 18.2436 43.6764 17.6774 43.4402 17.1538C43.2039 16.6303 42.8634 16.1604 42.4393 15.773C42.0153 15.3855 41.5167 15.0886 40.974 14.9004C40.4314 14.7122 39.856 14.6367 39.2831 14.6784C33.3907 14.6784 30.0009 19.0608 28.8076 23.9818H28.8815C30.191 19.3987 33.19 15.2486 38.4595 15.2486C38.9651 15.2017 39.475 15.2606 39.9566 15.4218C40.4383 15.5829 40.881 15.8427 41.2566 16.1845C41.6322 16.5263 41.9324 16.9426 42.1381 17.407C42.3438 17.8713 42.4504 18.3734 42.4511 18.8813C42.599 21.6586 41.2895 24.721 40.2441 27.5088L34.6895 41.7542H36.1679L41.6063 27.625C42.7679 24.721 43.9718 21.8275 43.8134 18.8179Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M41.184 18.9343C41.186 18.4922 41.0953 18.0545 40.918 17.6495C40.7406 17.2445 40.4804 16.8812 40.1542 16.5828C39.8279 16.2844 39.4428 16.0576 39.0237 15.917C38.6045 15.7763 38.1606 15.725 37.7204 15.7663C33.0951 15.7663 30.265 19.758 29.04 23.9925H29.1034C30.4023 20.0536 33.0634 16.3365 36.9072 16.3365C37.2753 16.3106 37.6447 16.3602 37.9928 16.4824C38.3409 16.6046 38.6603 16.7967 38.9314 17.047C39.2024 17.2973 39.4194 17.6004 39.5689 17.9377C39.7184 18.275 39.7973 18.6393 39.8007 19.0082C39.9168 21.2152 38.3962 24.7951 37.393 27.2978L31.68 41.7544H33.2112L38.8186 27.3928C39.8112 24.7845 41.2896 21.4898 41.184 18.9343Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M38.4911 19.103C38.4937 18.7969 38.4323 18.4937 38.3109 18.2128C38.1895 17.9318 38.0107 17.6794 37.786 17.4716C37.5613 17.2638 37.2956 17.1052 37.0061 17.0061C36.7165 16.907 36.4094 16.8694 36.1045 16.8959C32.9365 16.8959 30.4127 20.3385 29.2088 23.9817H29.2828C30.5394 20.7292 32.6936 17.4556 35.2808 17.4556C35.5185 17.428 35.7593 17.4522 35.9867 17.5264C36.2142 17.6007 36.4228 17.7233 36.5984 17.8858C36.774 18.0484 36.9123 18.247 37.0039 18.468C37.0954 18.689 37.1381 18.9273 37.1288 19.1663C37.2239 20.9193 35.4498 24.9004 34.605 27.1075L28.7336 41.7542H30.2015L35.9672 27.2236C36.9599 24.9004 38.5967 21.1199 38.4911 19.103Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M35.8302 19.2718C35.8462 19.0954 35.8234 18.9176 35.7634 18.7509C35.7034 18.5842 35.6077 18.4326 35.4829 18.3069C35.3582 18.1811 35.2074 18.0841 35.0412 18.0228C34.875 17.9615 34.6973 17.9373 34.5208 17.9518C32.6516 17.9518 30.6347 20.8981 29.4203 23.9605H29.4942C30.7192 21.236 32.6094 18.5115 33.7182 18.5115C34.1723 18.5115 34.468 18.7438 34.4996 19.3141C34.563 20.5074 32.5777 24.9848 31.7752 26.9173L25.7982 41.7013H27.2766L33.2008 27.0018C34.035 24.9531 35.9041 20.6974 35.8302 19.2718ZM19.684 31.8066L20.6344 29.8107L17.4136 13.3794C16.516 8.75409 17.5931 6.73713 21.2257 6.04017V5.97681H17.8676C16.8961 6.46257 14.8369 7.91985 15.988 13.3688L19.684 31.8066Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M17.783 35.7771L18.7229 33.7918L14.4989 13.2738C13.7069 9.29265 14.0448 7.22289 15.3648 6.04017V5.97681H13.0838C12.3869 7.46577 12.1757 8.95473 12.9782 12.8936L17.783 35.7771ZM15.84 39.7371L16.7798 37.773L11.4998 12.8408C10.5706 8.96529 10.7818 7.19121 11.1619 5.97681H9.14496C9.1239 8.07373 9.394 10.1634 9.94752 12.1861L15.84 39.7371ZM7.29696 5.97681H4.92096V6.04017C5.97696 7.32849 6.29376 8.90193 7.13856 12.3762L13.4746 41.7646H14.9002L8.56416 12.2811C8.01676 10.2068 7.59361 8.10158 7.29696 5.97681ZM2.54496 5.97681H0V6.04017C2.3232 6.95889 3.46368 8.72241 4.3824 12.8514L10.6445 41.7541H12.0701L5.76576 12.6718C4.67808 7.62417 3.5376 6.69489 2.54496 5.97681ZM34.9219 5.97681C31.9229 7.72977 30.1382 10.9717 26.4 19.0078L26.495 19.0606C30.8141 10.9717 33.2746 7.75089 38.8502 6.07185V5.97681H34.9219ZM26.1888 18.8494L26.2838 18.9128C29.832 10.5598 30.7613 8.22609 32.208 6.04017V5.97681H29.3357V6.06129C29.6314 9.40881 28.512 12.4923 26.1888 18.8494Z" fill="currentColor" />
        <path d="M25.9988 18.7227L26.0938 18.7861C28.3431 11.299 29.0718 7.99377 27.0865 5.97681H24.2881V6.04017C27.4561 7.15953 28.1108 10.3592 25.9988 18.7227ZM128.832 15.5864V17.012H128.621V15.5864H128.008V15.3858H129.466V15.5864H128.832ZM131.261 17.012V15.6286L130.754 16.9909H130.511L130.057 15.6286V17.012H129.856L129.92 15.3858H130.289L130.712 16.748L131.198 15.3858H131.535L131.599 17.012H131.261Z" fill="currentColor" />
      </g>
      <defs>
        <clipPath id="clip0_4_259">
          <rect width="132" height="42.24" fill="white" />
        </clipPath>
      </defs>
    </svg>;
};

export const DeliverooLogo = () => {
  return <svg width="140" height="82" viewBox="0 0 140 82" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
      <g clip-path="url(#clip0_4_124)">
        <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M54.3247 27.9655L53.7959 25.5015V10.8136H50.743V17.5135C49.8246 16.4542 48.5613 15.8335 47.0703 15.8335C44.016 15.8335 41.6523 18.3423 41.6523 22.0262C41.6523 25.7105 44.016 28.2198 47.0703 28.2198C48.5851 28.2198 49.8937 27.5744 50.8121 26.4689L51.1331 27.9655H54.3247ZM113.209 19.6541L114.655 16.408C113.989 15.9927 113.209 15.8093 112.452 15.8093C111.074 15.8093 109.926 16.429 109.192 17.5826L108.87 16.0846H105.725L106.23 18.4095V27.9627H109.282V20.3887C109.695 19.6061 110.476 19.1231 111.486 19.1231C112.107 19.124 112.68 19.2845 113.209 19.6527V19.6541ZM117.364 22.0248C117.364 20.1833 118.673 19.0335 120.439 19.0335C122.231 19.0335 123.517 20.1833 123.517 22.0248C123.517 23.8448 122.231 25.0185 120.44 25.0185C118.673 25.0185 117.363 23.8453 117.363 22.0257L117.364 22.0248ZM44.6129 22.0248C44.6129 20.1833 45.9209 19.0335 47.6882 19.0335C49.4802 19.0335 50.7649 20.1833 50.7649 22.0248C50.7649 23.8448 49.4797 25.0185 47.6896 25.0185C45.9219 25.0185 44.6124 23.8453 44.6124 22.0257L44.6129 22.0248ZM133.962 25.0185C132.195 25.0185 130.886 23.8453 130.886 22.0257C130.886 20.1838 132.195 19.0335 133.962 19.0335C135.752 19.0335 137.037 20.1838 137.037 22.0257C137.037 23.8457 135.752 25.0185 133.962 25.0185ZM64.6772 20.944H58.8009C59.1453 19.586 60.1776 18.8487 61.7386 18.8487C63.3229 18.8487 64.3566 19.586 64.6772 20.944ZM101.202 20.944H95.326C95.6699 19.586 96.7027 18.8487 98.2637 18.8487C99.848 18.8487 100.882 19.586 101.202 20.944ZM88.2779 27.9664L91.4699 16.0865H88.1407L85.7999 25.7101L83.4573 16.086H80.1743L83.3663 27.965H88.2779V27.9664ZM75.4913 27.9664H78.5423V16.0851H75.4903V27.9655L75.4913 27.9664ZM66.9825 26.8277L65.8121 24.2037C64.7099 24.7791 63.4928 25.1244 62.2533 25.1244C60.6471 25.1244 59.5219 24.5028 59.0394 23.3511H67.6247C67.7166 22.9143 67.7633 22.477 67.7633 21.9473C67.7633 18.2635 65.2153 15.7999 61.7946 15.7999C58.3515 15.7999 55.8259 18.2873 55.8259 21.9935C55.8259 25.7689 58.3282 28.1862 62.2081 28.1862C63.9067 28.1862 65.5821 27.7256 66.9821 26.8282L66.9825 26.8277ZM133.962 15.8331C130.495 15.8331 127.925 18.3423 127.925 22.0257C127.925 25.7105 130.496 28.2193 133.962 28.2193C137.429 28.2193 140 25.7105 140 22.0267C140 18.3423 137.429 15.8331 133.962 15.8331ZM103.453 26.8604L102.282 24.2354C101.179 24.8113 99.9623 25.1561 98.7224 25.1561C97.1157 25.1561 95.9905 24.5355 95.5085 23.3828H104.095C104.187 22.946 104.232 22.5087 104.232 21.9795C104.232 18.2957 101.684 15.8321 98.2637 15.8321C94.8197 15.8321 92.295 18.3181 92.295 22.0257C92.295 25.8011 94.7977 28.2184 98.6771 28.2184C100.376 28.2198 102.051 27.7597 103.453 26.8613L103.453 26.8604ZM126.477 22.0257C126.477 18.3423 123.906 15.8331 120.44 15.8331C116.972 15.8331 114.402 18.3423 114.402 22.0257C114.402 25.7105 116.973 28.2193 120.439 28.2193C123.907 28.2193 126.478 25.7105 126.478 22.0267L126.477 22.0257ZM72.758 27.9659V10.8127H69.7051V27.965H72.758V27.9659ZM78.9334 12.5155C78.9334 11.4105 78.1074 10.5817 77.0285 10.5817C75.9271 10.5817 75.1011 11.4105 75.1011 12.5155C75.1011 13.6206 75.9271 14.4494 77.0294 14.4494C78.1074 14.4494 78.9334 13.6206 78.9334 12.5155ZM22.8275 16.4621L19.8455 2.58347L10.4981 4.55047L13.4778 18.4291L0 21.2627L2.38 32.3493L26.082 37.3333L31.5019 25.2873L34.0807 0.989333L24.5747 0L22.8275 16.4621ZM15.2656 24.0576C14.5815 23.8327 14.2772 23.0137 14.5367 22.0229C14.7299 21.2879 15.6389 21.1783 16.0939 21.1699C16.2666 21.1671 16.4369 21.2016 16.5933 21.2716C16.9153 21.4163 17.4599 21.7233 17.5705 22.1923C17.7305 22.869 17.5765 23.4369 17.0879 23.8798C16.5979 24.3245 15.9521 24.2839 15.2661 24.0581L15.2656 24.0576ZM21.7439 24.892C21.126 24.5924 21.1307 23.8294 21.1979 23.3641C21.2343 23.1107 21.3369 22.8718 21.4975 22.6702C21.7182 22.393 22.0869 22.0323 22.5125 22.0215C23.2055 22.0029 23.8014 22.3109 24.1379 22.8671C24.4757 23.4215 24.3068 24.0329 23.9512 24.6451C23.5933 25.2551 22.6613 25.3363 21.7439 24.892Z" fill="currentColor" />
      </g>
      <defs>
        <clipPath id="clip0_4_124">
          <rect width="140" height="37.3333" fill="white" />
        </clipPath>
      </defs>
    </svg>;
};

## Questions answered

* [Where are my users dropping off?](#where-are-my-users-dropping-off)
* [Should B2B and B2C companies measure drop off on their user's path to value differently?](#should-b2b-and-b2c-companies-measure-drop-off-on-their-users-path-to-value-differently)
* [How can I measure user drop off?](#how-can-i-measure-user-drop-off)
* [Why should I measure retention?](#why-should-i-measure-retention)
* [How do I measure retention?](#how-do-i-measure-retention)
* [When it comes to retention, what's the difference between a good PM and a great PM?](#when-it-comes-to-retention-whats-the-difference-between-a-good-pm-and-a-great-pm)
* [Who are my most retained users?](#who-are-my-most-retained-users)

In previous chapters, we've established that the most successful products are those that bring the most value to users. That's why measuring value is key to product analytics, whether it's defining activation, tracking the growth of DAU/WAU/MAU, or grouping users by their level of engagement.

Some products can deliver an incredible amount of value in a single value moment. For example, you download an AR measuring app, use it once when you buy a couch, and delete it for good. You open a dating app, swipe on the first person you see, fall in love at first sight, and never use the app again. **But for most digital products, the only way to bring a lot of value to users is to keep them coming back regularly and engaging with your product.**

## Where are my users dropping off?

Users are more likely to retain when they successfully experience value in your product early and often. But somewhere on their path to value, at least some users are going to drop off. So it's not surprising that one of the most popular questions in product analytics is (and something our support team at Mixpanel gets asked frequently) **"Where are my users dropping off?"**

To realize the value of your business, a user needs to survive two key drop offs in their product journey:

1. **The value moment**, which is key to activation, engagement, and retention (the moment when they get value)
2. **The value exchange** (or payment), which is essential to monetization and business health (the moment when you get value)

<Frame>
  <img src="https://mintcdn.com/mixpanel-edb78807/75RViqPwRfiQUDDl/images/UserDropoffChart.png?fit=max&auto=format&n=75RViqPwRfiQUDDl&q=85&s=c66b3b19968a8c6422f95c7c3263f8f0" alt="image" width="2924" height="836" data-path="images/UserDropoffChart.png" />
</Frame>

The value moments for the user and the business are sometimes the same. For example, the value moment in shopping apps (e.g., "complete checkout") is naturally tied to revenue. People get value when they buy an item they like; shops get value when people buy that item.

More often, however, the journey to value and the journey to value exchange in digital products are two different journeys. For a fitness app like ClassPass, for example, people get the value when they complete workouts, while ClassPass gets value when people buy workout credits.

Which one of the two drop offs should you focus on? Focusing on value is more helpful for building better products than focusing on revenue. If you optimize your product to get users to pay you but don’t optimize for the value they get, soon you will have a churn problem. In fact, it’s the perfect way to end up with a leaky bucket—many customers who pay once and never come back. This goes back to the point made earlier in the book: if people don’t get value from your product, they won’t use it, and of course they won’t pay for it.

**Key insights:**

* Drop-offs most often occur before the value exchange moment (e.g., before a person submits their credit card information, makes a purchase, etc.).
* The more important drop-off point to track, however, is the drop-off before the value moment. The more people reach value in your product, the more people will reach value exchange.
* The fewer steps to get to the value moment, the fewer points of drop-off you'll encounter.

## Should B2B and B2C companies measure drop off on their user's path to value differently?

**No.** B2B enterprise products are also no longer immune to this type of churn. For a while, CTOs, CIOs, and CEOs of Fortune 2000 companies were purchasing software based on what the analyst firms told them (regardless of whether end users liked or hated the software). But now, especially with freemium products, employees often trial different tools, or purchase paid plans with their credit card, and then expense it (until their IT department figures out that it makes more sense to get a company license). And in many cases, SaaS contracts don’t get renewed shortly after an email goes out to the team with the subject line: “Does anyone use this?”

**Enterprise buyers are not that different from consumers now.** So for any product, B2C or B2B, understanding and measuring value comes first.

## How can I measure user drop off?

We've established that the end goal—the moment where value is realized—should be crystal clear, as should the points leading up to that moment. **If users open your app or product for the first time, what is the shortest and most ideal path to the value moment?** That is the funnel to work with.

Each step, screen, page, or button in that journey is critical and the conversion from one to the next will point you to the areas you need to optimize.

The Mixpanel Funnels report helps you understand and measure drop off within a product.

To build a funnel, head over to the Funnels report in Mixpanel and add steps by selecting events from the drop-down list.

For example, when you select "sign up" and "watch video," you'll see how many people out of those who sign up go on to watch a video. Use filters and exclusion steps (e.g., "exclude users who did not do X") and modify conversion criteria (e.g., rearrange the order or select "any order funnels") to customize your question for Mixpanel.

If you’re thinking, “My product is too complex and unique to have a single path to value,” this is a sign of an insufficiently thought-out product. If you can’t express the path to value and build a funnel, go back to the “sign up” page of your product. As a user, go through all the steps to define the dominant canonical journey in your product.

### Key Questions to Ask

With this funnel in mind, as a PM you can expand the range of questions and ways to focus:

* **Where is the lowest conversion rate?**
* **Do converted users share certain characteristics of behavior?**
* **Are users performing certain steps more than once?**
* **Do users get hung up on certain steps longer than on others?**

And finally, "Where are my users dropping off?" is a good question to ask, but only if you get to the question behind it: **"Where should I direct my resources and creativity to increase the number of users that reach the value moment?"**

### Industry Example

<div className="flex items-start gap-5 justify-between my-[50px] max-[766px]:block">
  <DeliverooLogo />

  <div className="w-4/5 max-[766px]:w-full">
    "Deliveroo wants to ensure its restaurant partners are successful, that they get orders and high ROI from using the company's services. We look closely at the conversion funnel from sign up to the first order. For each market, we have targets we want partners to hit, so we know they are reducing churn and increasing conversion. We track how well our restaurant partners are doing on the platform. Are they engaged? Are they taking actions that are good indicators of whether they're going to be successful? How long has it taken them to onboard? We want our partners to be able to go from making the decision to be on Deliveroo to actually taking their first order in a matter of hours, and being able to look at these metrics is what's going to enable us to do that."<div className="text-base mt-4">**Jordan Ng**</div> *Senior Product Manager, Deliveroo*
  </div>
</div>

## Why should I measure retention?

So: you've mastered conversion analysis, tracked your users' journey to their first value moment, and then streamlined your UX so as many users as possible reach the value exchange moment where you actually make some revenue. Congratulations!

However: **in a world where every user knows what is best for themselves and can delete your app or unsubscribe from your product at the click of a link, your product can survive only if it repeatedly brings value to users.** As with a reality show, you might win the challenge one week, but everything resets for next week’s challenge, and if you don’t show up and bring value, you might just get cut.

It's not enough to ask: "Does my product bring value to users?" Instead, you have to ask **"Does my product bring value to users—over and over and over again?"**

To put it another way: "Grey's Anatomy" remains on air after 16 years because, after all this time, it still brings an addictive emotional release. **Is your product the "Grey's Anatomy" of your industry? Or will it be cancelled after one season?**

### Common Retention Mistakes

With this in mind, as a PM, you don’t need convincing that measuring retention or churn is valuable. You’re probably already tracking it, with product analytics or in some other way. But the key is not to set out to “fix churn” through interdepartmental task forces and changes to your pricing model. You’ll need to fix your product itself. Low churn and high retention rate are two sides of the same coin—and reliable signals of lasting product success.

Retention data can show you which customers are more likely to stay, and how they compare to those who churn. Such insights are helpful by themselves, but even more so as a starting point for more qualitative digging. The paths and actions that retained users take in your product can inspire product optimizations that help more new users find value faster and stick around for longer.

Since retention is simply the percent of users who stay with your product and continue using it in a given period, calculating it is pretty straightforward. You just take the number of your active users during that period divided by the number of active users at the beginning of the period. And yet PMs often get this metric wrong.<sup>4</sup> Brian Balfour from Reforge says that there are three mistakes companies make when defining their retention metric:

#### Focus on revenue

SaaS companies often focus on monthly or annual revenue retention instead of measuring the frequency and depth of product usage.

#### Choosing the wrong frequency

Some products should focus on daily retention vs. weekly or monthly. This depends on your product's natural usage interval.

#### Failure to tie retention back to value

Your retention metric should reflect the number of retained users who experience value. Defining what "active" means for your product is a great place to start.

### Industry Example

<div className="flex items-start gap-5 justify-between my-[50px] max-[766px]:block">
  <DeliverooLogo />

  <div className="w-4/5 max-[766px]:w-full">
    "Deliveroo looks at one-week and three-week retention to see if restaurants are engaging with the platform. Are they finding value in using Hub? You don't necessarily need to use Hub to get orders. You could get set up and then completely go on autopilot and your orders can come in. You may not necessarily need to come back to that portal, but we want to help you grow and manage your business. It's an opportunity for us to educate you, give direction, and help you improve your business so we want to measure that engagement and retention."<div className="text-base mt-4">**Jordan Ng**</div> *Senior Product Manager, Deliveroo*
  </div>
</div>

## How do I measure retention?

**N Day retention** calculates the percentage of users who come back on a specific day.

**Unbounded retention** calculates the percentage of users who come back on a specific day (or week, month, etc.) or any time unit afterwards.

To analyze retention in Mixpanel, select up to two events to see how many people come back to perform the same event.

## When it comes to retention, what's the difference between a good PM and a great PM?

Remember how you identified the user interaction that symbolizes the moment when your users get value back? That should be the metric that you build your retention reports around. **A good PM gets this far and, once a month, they look at the report to see if things went up or down, they nod, and then go back to not looking at it.**

**A great PM focuses on the users that are getting the most value**—they are likely the best fit for your product. A common misstep for new PMs is to focus on the users that churned and obsess about how to get them back. Instead, **obsess over the users that are getting value**. Look at the full breadth of behavior for those users; interview them; send them an email; offer them a gift card in exchange for 15 minutes of their time. Build the best, most valuable product for these users and you won't have a churn problem in the first place.

### Expert Perspectives

<div className="flex items-start gap-5 justify-between my-[50px] max-[766px]:block">
  <ZipRecruiterLogo />

  <div className="w-4/5 max-[766px]:w-full">
    "A good PM builds a value-moment retention report and analyses on a regular cadence. They can make conjectures about how feature releases or product updates impacted retention rate. A great PM breaks down retention data by cohorts to understand what causes churn. They obsess over the users that get the most value, connect with their use cases, and build features specifically for them.

    A great PM works with their data science team on a definition that makes sense for the business. They also account for 'happy churn.' Especially with transactional services, some users churn because your service works as intended, which is a good thing."<div className="text-base mt-4">**Akio Bandle**</div> *Senior Product Manager, ZipRecruiter*
  </div>
</div>

<div className="flex items-start gap-5 justify-between my-[50px] max-[766px]:block">
  <VrboLogo />

  <div className="w-4/5 max-[766px]:w-full">
    "A great PM understands the difference between correlation and causation; they can figure out that a higher conversion rate among more intentful visitors is not a signal that they need to drive that particular user behavior, but that it's a function of the way they've built their analysis. They don't go after opportunities based on that information and then find themselves in a position where they have to defend their sizing of that opportunity and why they prioritized that work.

    A great product manager needs to see the difference between an actual trend that can be corrected or adjusted... and a data point."<div className="text-base mt-4">**John Meakin**</div> *Lead Statistician, Vrbo, part of Expedia Group*
  </div>
</div>

## Who are my most retained users?

Mixpanel can help you understand which users are sticking around longer and continue to get value.

You can create cohorts for retained users directly from the Retention report. Simply click a segment of the Retention report, and click the "create cohort" button.

You can then investigate what causes your users to be retained by exploring the different properties of your "retained users" cohort in the Insights report.

<Frame>
  <img src="https://mintcdn.com/mixpanel-edb78807/ogXlzma9enlXzenB/images/retained_gif.gif?s=cb8370b1823a1318b3f4c387d4914d3d" alt="image" width="1224" height="710" data-path="images/retained_gif.gif" />
</Frame>

<Note>
  4. Why Retention is the Silent Killer (2017). Reforge.
     [https://www.reforge.com/blog/retention-engagement-growth-silent-killer](https://www.reforge.com/blog/retention-engagement-growth-silent-killer)
</Note>

## Next Steps

### Grow and scale

Now that you understand retention and how to identify your most valuable users, the next chapter focuses on growth strategies and scaling your product.

[Read Chapter 5 →](/guides/strategic-playbooks/guide-to-product-analytics/grow-and-scale)
